I really enjoyed this novel-though at first I thought it was really weird. This is a unique novel aimed for middle school students about a "community" or society that is all about Sameness. Though you don't realize it until later in the book, the oddities of the community are apparent at the beginning of the book. I knew this upon reading about all the rules, of only having one boy and one girl child, of "The Pill", of "release", etc.
I thought it was interesting how all the people had their own "jobs" in the community and it was chosen for them. Sounds like a community with no choice, not seeing colors, not having feelings or knowing love, etc. I was so glad at the end of the book that Jonas got out of there with Gabe-and hopefully left some of his memories so the community could recoop. Though the community was safe because nothing unusual happened, not having feelings kind of beats the purpose of life. I think this story was so interesting and praise Lowry for her imagination in creating this kind of futuristic-seeming society. I was frustrated and saddened at the concept of release, and joyful when Jonas experienced the memories and learned the warmth (and struggles) from them.
Awesome book, would use this in the classroom (for older students-upper elementary to middle school) for them to read, would have the class read it as a whole like we did and discuss it. It's no wonder it's a Newberry Medal winner! There are many extension activites that could come from this novel, similar to what we did in this children's literature class. I definitely think it would be interesting to have students do the "sketch" responses from each of the chapters, and to see if they do use color or just black and white when making their sketch. Another activity I think would be great is for students to write a question they have about the novel, and be in small groups and have the other students discuss it except for them. During my discussion with classmates, we all had so many questions about this community that I think this activity would be great to do. As one student suggested, too, I think it would be interesting for students to read this book every two years for a few grade levels, and see what they get from this book each time, as I think more observations would be made each time. Another activity I think would be good to do is have students keep a journal throughout reading the book of how they feel, since the point of view is pretty solitary (being of Jonas'). This book has so many tools to use in the classroom!